Back to Blog

HEVC vs H.264: The Complete Codec Guide

Everything you need to know about choosing the right video codec for your needs

January 10, 2025
8 min read
Bonsai Team
codecs HEVC H.264 compression technical

Understanding Video Codecs: The Foundation of Compression

Video codecs are the invisible workhorses behind every video file on your device. They determine how your videos are compressed, stored, and played back. When using Bonsai to optimize your video library, choosing the right codec can make a significant difference in both file size and compatibility.

What Are HEVC and H.264?

H.264 (Advanced Video Coding)

H.264, also known as AVC (Advanced Video Coding), has been the gold standard for video compression since 2003. It's widely supported across virtually every device, platform, and service you can imagine.

Key characteristics:

  • Mature, stable technology
  • Universal compatibility
  • Excellent quality at moderate compression ratios
  • Higher CPU requirements for encoding
  • Larger file sizes compared to newer codecs

HEVC (High Efficiency Video Coding)

HEVC, also known as H.265, is the successor to H.264, finalized in 2013. It was designed to provide significantly better compression while maintaining the same visual quality.

Key characteristics:

  • Up to 50% smaller file sizes than H.264
  • Supports higher resolutions (4K, 8K) more efficiently
  • Better handling of high dynamic range (HDR) content
  • Requires more processing power for encoding/decoding
  • Limited compatibility on older devices

The Compression Battle: Numbers Don't Lie

When comparing HEVC to H.264 at the same quality level, the differences are substantial:

File Size Comparison

  • 4K 60fps video (1 minute):

    • H.264: ~400MB
    • HEVC: ~200MB (50% reduction)

  • 1080p 30fps video (1 minute):

    • H.264: ~150MB
    • HEVC: ~75MB (50% reduction)

  • 720p 30fps video (1 minute):

    • H.264: ~70MB
    • HEVC: ~35MB (50% reduction)

Quality Retention

Both codecs can achieve visually identical results, but HEVC does it with significantly less data. This means you can either:

  1. Keep the same file size and get better quality
  2. Keep the same quality and get smaller files
  3. Find a sweet spot with slightly better quality AND smaller files

Device Compatibility: The Real-World Factor

H.264 Compatibility

✅ Universal Support:

  • All iPhones, iPads, Macs (2007+)
  • All Android devices
  • All Windows computers
  • All streaming platforms (YouTube, Netflix, etc.)
  • All social media platforms
  • All video editing software
  • All smart TVs and media players

HEVC Compatibility

⚠️ Selective Support:

✅ Full Support:

  • iPhone 7 and newer
  • iPad Pro (2017+), iPad Air (3rd gen+), iPad mini (5th gen+)
  • Mac computers with Apple Silicon or Intel (2016+)
  • Apple TV 4K
  • Windows 10/11 (with codec pack)

❌ Limited/No Support:

  • iPhone 6s and older
  • Older Android devices
  • Some older Windows computers
  • Many older TVs and media players
  • Some video editing software (without updates)

When to Choose H.264

Perfect for:

  1. Maximum Compatibility - When you need to ensure your videos play everywhere
  2. Sharing and Distribution - Social media, email, cloud sharing
  3. Legacy Device Support - Working with older equipment
  4. Professional Workflows - Many editing suites still default to H.264
  5. Live Streaming - Better real-time encoding performance

Real-World Scenarios:

  • Videos for your grandparents' older iPad
  • Content for YouTube or social media
  • Projects requiring broad compatibility
  • Quick shares via messaging apps
  • Archival footage that needs to be accessible long-term

When to Choose HEVC

Perfect for:

  1. Storage Optimization - Maximizing space on your devices
  2. 4K/8K Content - High-resolution videos compress much better
  3. Personal Archive - Modern device ecosystem
  4. iCloud Storage Savings - Reduce cloud storage costs
  5. Future-Proofing - Newer devices handle HEVC efficiently

Real-World Scenarios:

  • Personal family videos for modern Apple devices
  • 4K vacation footage taking up too much space
  • Professional proxy files for editing
  • Content consumed primarily on newer devices
  • Building a long-term digital archive

Bonsai's Smart Approach

Bonsai makes codec selection intelligent and automatic:

Auto Recommendation Engine

Our app analyzes your video characteristics and suggests the optimal codec based on:

  • Original resolution and bitrate
  • Target file size goals
  • Device compatibility requirements
  • Quality preservation needs

Manual Override Option

For power users, Bonsai provides full manual control:

  • Choose specific codecs for different use cases
  • Set custom quality and compression settings
  • Create presets for different workflows
  • Batch process with consistent settings

Performance Considerations

Encoding Speed

  • H.264: Faster encoding, especially on older devices
  • HEVC: Slower encoding but much more efficient compression

Playback Performance

  • H.264: Lower CPU usage during playback
  • HEVC: Higher CPU usage but manageable on modern devices

Battery Impact

  • H.264: Less battery drain during encoding/playback
  • HEVC: More intensive but offset by smaller file sizes

Best Practices and Recommendations

The Hybrid Approach

Many users find success with a mixed strategy:

  1. HEVC for personal storage - Your device and iCloud library
  2. H.264 for sharing - When sending to others or posting online
  3. HEVC for 4K content - The compression benefits are too significant to ignore
  4. H.264 for older content - May not be worth re-encoding

Quality Settings Sweet Spots

Based on extensive testing, these settings provide excellent quality-to-size ratios:

For HEVC:

  • 4K content: CRF 23-25
  • 1080p content: CRF 25-27
  • 720p content: CRF 27-29

For H.264:

  • 4K content: CRF 20-22
  • 1080p content: CRF 22-24
  • 720p content: CRF 24-26

The Future is HEVC (and Beyond)

While H.264 remains important for compatibility, the industry is clearly moving toward HEVC and even newer codecs like AV1. Apple's ecosystem has fully embraced HEVC, and it's the default for new recordings on modern devices.

What This Means for You:

  • New content: Consider HEVC as your primary codec
  • Sharing content: Keep H.264 in your toolkit
  • Archive strategy: HEVC for long-term storage efficiency
  • Device upgrades: HEVC benefits increase with newer hardware

Making the Right Choice

The "best" codec depends entirely on your specific needs:

Choose H.264 if:

  • Compatibility is your top priority
  • You frequently share videos with others
  • You work with older devices or software
  • File size is less of a concern than universal playback

Choose HEVC if:

  • Storage space is at a premium
  • You work primarily within Apple's ecosystem
  • You shoot a lot of 4K content
  • You want future-proof video files
  • iCloud storage costs are a concern

Conclusion

Both HEVC and H.264 have their place in a modern video workflow. The key is understanding when to use each codec and having tools like Bonsai that make it easy to choose the right option for each situation.

Remember: the best codec is the one that meets your specific needs for quality, file size, and compatibility. With Bonsai's intelligent recommendations and manual controls, you have the flexibility to optimize every video in your library perfectly.

Want to see these codecs in action? Download Bonsai and try both options with your own videos to see the difference firsthand.